Compliments: I really enjoyed the relationship shown between Emma and Tim! They seemed realistic together - Emma shouting at him to lint roll everything and him being like really? - that and other little moments are really telling of their dynamic. You also had a good sense of humor throughout, nothing too cheesy but still got the character's personality to show through.
Revisions: Be careful of 'movie dialogue'- I liked your dialogue because I thought it characterized Emma well, but I think the overall tone and word choice of the interactions between the characters are a little movie-like and not totally realistic, mainly between Emma and Caroline. There are some grammatical errors - quotation punctuation, comma errors, contractions - simple things to be changed. Overall, I would have liked to see this pressing problem of impressing the mother-in-law to be more pressing. Emma and Caroline seem to have a good relationship, no obvious tension or bitterness or anything like that, and I think there should be a true reason for wanting to impress her, besides her being her mother-in-law. However, be careful not to make this relationship too cliche - everyone's seen Monster In-Law, everyone's heard stories of mother in- laws not liking their daughter in-laws - so keep it unique!
Overall, this is a cute story and a great start!
No comments:
Post a Comment